differential_dataflow/operators/

join.rs

//! Match pairs of records based on a key.
//!
//! The various `join` implementations require that the units of each collection can be multiplied, and that
//! the multiplication distributes over addition. That is, we will repeatedly evaluate (a + b) * c as (a * c)
//! + (b * c), and if this is not equal to the former term, little is known about the actual output.
use std::cmp::Ordering;
use timely::Container;

use timely::container::{ContainerBuilder, PushInto};
use timely::order::PartialOrder;
use timely::progress::Timestamp;
use timely::dataflow::{Scope, StreamCore};
use timely::dataflow::operators::generic::{Operator, OutputHandleCore};
use timely::dataflow::channels::pact::Pipeline;
use timely::dataflow::channels::pushers::buffer::Session;
use timely::dataflow::channels::pushers::Counter;
use timely::dataflow::operators::Capability;
use timely::dataflow::channels::pushers::tee::Tee;

use crate::hashable::Hashable;
use crate::{Data, ExchangeData, Collection};
use crate::difference::{Semigroup, Abelian, Multiply};
use crate::lattice::Lattice;
use crate::operators::arrange::{Arranged, ArrangeByKey, ArrangeBySelf};
use crate::trace::{BatchReader, Cursor};
use crate::operators::ValueHistory;

use crate::trace::TraceReader;

/// Join implementations for `(key,val)` data.
pub trait Join<G: Scope, K: Data, V: Data, R: Semigroup> {

    /// Matches pairs `(key,val1)` and `(key,val2)` based on `key` and yields pairs `(key, (val1, val2))`.
    ///
    /// The [`join_map`](Join::join_map) method may be more convenient for non-trivial processing pipelines.
    ///
    /// # Examples
    ///
    /// ```
    /// use differential_dataflow::input::Input;
    /// use differential_dataflow::operators::Join;
    ///
    /// ::timely::example(|scope| {
    ///
    ///     let x = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(0, 1), (1, 3)]).1;
    ///     let y = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(0, 'a'), (1, 'b')]).1;
    ///     let z = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(0, (1, 'a')), (1, (3, 'b'))]).1;
    ///
    ///     x.join(&y)
    ///      .assert_eq(&z);
    /// });
    /// ```
    fn join<V2, R2>(&self, other: &Collection<G, (K,V2), R2>) -> Collection<G, (K,(V,V2)), <R as Multiply<R2>>::Output>
    where
        K: ExchangeData,
        V2: ExchangeData,
        R2: ExchangeData+Semigroup,
        R: Multiply<R2>,
        <R as Multiply<R2>>::Output: Semigroup+'static
    {
        self.join_map(other, |k,v,v2| (k.clone(),(v.clone(),v2.clone())))
    }

    /// Matches pairs `(key,val1)` and `(key,val2)` based on `key` and then applies a function.
    ///
    /// # Examples
    ///
    /// ```
    /// use differential_dataflow::input::Input;
    /// use differential_dataflow::operators::Join;
    ///
    /// ::timely::example(|scope| {
    ///
    ///     let x = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(0, 1), (1, 3)]).1;
    ///     let y = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(0, 'a'), (1, 'b')]).1;
    ///     let z = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(1, 'a'), (3, 'b')]).1;
    ///
    ///     x.join_map(&y, |_key, &a, &b| (a,b))
    ///      .assert_eq(&z);
    /// });
    /// ```
    fn join_map<V2, R2, D, L>(&self, other: &Collection<G, (K,V2), R2>, logic: L) -> Collection<G, D, <R as Multiply<R2>>::Output>
    where K: ExchangeData, V2: ExchangeData, R2: ExchangeData+Semigroup, R: Multiply<R2>, <R as Multiply<R2>>::Output: Semigroup+'static, D: Data, L: FnMut(&K, &V, &V2)->D+'static;

    /// Matches pairs `(key, val)` and `key` based on `key`, producing the former with frequencies multiplied.
    ///
    /// When the second collection contains frequencies that are either zero or one this is the more traditional
    /// relational semijoin. When the second collection may contain multiplicities, this operation may scale up
    /// the counts of the records in the first input.
    ///
    /// # Examples
    ///
    /// ```
    /// use differential_dataflow::input::Input;
    /// use differential_dataflow::operators::Join;
    ///
    /// ::timely::example(|scope| {
    ///
    ///     let x = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(0, 1), (1, 3)]).1;
    ///     let y = scope.new_collection_from(vec![0, 2]).1;
    ///     let z = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(0, 1)]).1;
    ///
    ///     x.semijoin(&y)
    ///      .assert_eq(&z);
    /// });
    /// ```
    fn semijoin<R2>(&self, other: &Collection<G, K, R2>) -> Collection<G, (K, V), <R as Multiply<R2>>::Output>
    where K: ExchangeData, R2: ExchangeData+Semigroup, R: Multiply<R2>, <R as Multiply<R2>>::Output: Semigroup+'static;

    /// Subtracts the semijoin with `other` from `self`.
    ///
    /// In the case that `other` has multiplicities zero or one this results
    /// in a relational antijoin, in which we discard input records whose key
    /// is present in `other`. If the multiplicities could be other than zero
    /// or one, the semantic interpretation of this operator is less clear.
    ///
    /// In almost all cases, you should ensure that `other` has multiplicities
    /// that are zero or one, perhaps by using the `distinct` operator.
    ///
    /// # Examples
    ///
    /// ```
    /// use differential_dataflow::input::Input;
    /// use differential_dataflow::operators::Join;
    ///
    /// ::timely::example(|scope| {
    ///
    ///     let x = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(0, 1), (1, 3)]).1;
    ///     let y = scope.new_collection_from(vec![0, 2]).1;
    ///     let z = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(1, 3)]).1;
    ///
    ///     x.antijoin(&y)
    ///      .assert_eq(&z);
    /// });
    /// ```
    fn antijoin<R2>(&self, other: &Collection<G, K, R2>) -> Collection<G, (K, V), R>
    where K: ExchangeData, R2: ExchangeData+Semigroup, R: Multiply<R2, Output = R>, R: Abelian+'static;
}

impl<G, K, V, R> Join<G, K, V, R> for Collection<G, (K, V), R>
where
    G: Scope,
    K: ExchangeData+Hashable,
    V: ExchangeData,
    R: ExchangeData+Semigroup,
    G::Timestamp: Lattice+Ord,
{
    fn join_map<V2: ExchangeData, R2: ExchangeData+Semigroup, D: Data, L>(&self, other: &Collection<G, (K, V2), R2>, mut logic: L) -> Collection<G, D, <R as Multiply<R2>>::Output>
    where R: Multiply<R2>, <R as Multiply<R2>>::Output: Semigroup+'static, L: FnMut(&K, &V, &V2)->D+'static {
        let arranged1 = self.arrange_by_key();
        let arranged2 = other.arrange_by_key();
        arranged1.join_core(&arranged2, move |k,v1,v2| Some(logic(k,v1,v2)))
    }

    fn semijoin<R2: ExchangeData+Semigroup>(&self, other: &Collection<G, K, R2>) -> Collection<G, (K, V), <R as Multiply<R2>>::Output>
    where R: Multiply<R2>, <R as Multiply<R2>>::Output: Semigroup+'static {
        let arranged1 = self.arrange_by_key();
        let arranged2 = other.arrange_by_self();
        arranged1.join_core(&arranged2, |k,v,_| Some((k.clone(), v.clone())))
    }

    fn antijoin<R2: ExchangeData+Semigroup>(&self, other: &Collection<G, K, R2>) -> Collection<G, (K, V), R>
    where R: Multiply<R2, Output=R>, R: Abelian+'static {
        self.concat(&self.semijoin(other).negate())
    }
}

impl<G, K, V, Tr> Join<G, K, V, Tr::Diff> for Arranged<G, Tr>
where
    G: Scope<Timestamp=Tr::Time>,
    Tr: for<'a> TraceReader<Key<'a> = &'a K, Val<'a> = &'a V>+Clone+'static,
    K: ExchangeData+Hashable,
    V: Data + 'static,
{
    fn join_map<V2: ExchangeData, R2: ExchangeData+Semigroup, D: Data, L>(&self, other: &Collection<G, (K, V2), R2>, mut logic: L) -> Collection<G, D, <Tr::Diff as Multiply<R2>>::Output>
    where 
        Tr::Diff: Multiply<R2>,
        <Tr::Diff as Multiply<R2>>::Output: Semigroup+'static,
        L: for<'a> FnMut(Tr::Key<'a>, Tr::Val<'a>, &V2)->D+'static,
    {
        let arranged2 = other.arrange_by_key();
        self.join_core(&arranged2, move |k,v1,v2| Some(logic(k,v1,v2)))
    }

    fn semijoin<R2: ExchangeData+Semigroup>(&self, other: &Collection<G, K, R2>) -> Collection<G, (K, V), <Tr::Diff as Multiply<R2>>::Output>
    where Tr::Diff: Multiply<R2>, <Tr::Diff as Multiply<R2>>::Output: Semigroup+'static {
        let arranged2 = other.arrange_by_self();
        self.join_core(&arranged2, |k,v,_| Some((k.clone(), v.clone())))
    }

    fn antijoin<R2: ExchangeData+Semigroup>(&self, other: &Collection<G, K, R2>) -> Collection<G, (K, V), Tr::Diff>
    where Tr::Diff: Multiply<R2, Output=Tr::Diff>, Tr::Diff: Abelian+'static {
        self.as_collection(|k,v| (k.clone(), v.clone()))
            .concat(&self.semijoin(other).negate())
    }
}

/// Matches the elements of two arranged traces.
///
/// This method is used by the various `join` implementations, but it can also be used
/// directly in the event that one has a handle to an `Arranged<G,T>`, perhaps because
/// the arrangement is available for re-use, or from the output of a `reduce` operator.
pub trait JoinCore<G: Scope, K: 'static + ?Sized, V: 'static + ?Sized, R: Semigroup> where G::Timestamp: Lattice+Ord {

    /// Joins two arranged collections with the same key type.
    ///
    /// Each matching pair of records `(key, val1)` and `(key, val2)` are subjected to the `result` function,
    /// which produces something implementing `IntoIterator`, where the output collection will have an entry for
    /// every value returned by the iterator.
    ///
    /// This trait is implemented for arrangements (`Arranged<G, T>`) rather than collections. The `Join` trait
    /// contains the implementations for collections.
    ///
    /// # Examples
    ///
    /// ```
    /// use differential_dataflow::input::Input;
    /// use differential_dataflow::operators::arrange::ArrangeByKey;
    /// use differential_dataflow::operators::join::JoinCore;
    /// use differential_dataflow::trace::Trace;
    ///
    /// ::timely::example(|scope| {
    ///
    ///     let x = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(0u32, 1), (1, 3)]).1
    ///                  .arrange_by_key();
    ///     let y = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(0, 'a'), (1, 'b')]).1
    ///                  .arrange_by_key();
    ///
    ///     let z = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(1, 'a'), (3, 'b')]).1;
    ///
    ///     x.join_core(&y, |_key, &a, &b| Some((a, b)))
    ///      .assert_eq(&z);
    /// });
    /// ```
    fn join_core<Tr2,I,L> (&self, stream2: &Arranged<G,Tr2>, result: L) -> Collection<G,I::Item,<R as Multiply<Tr2::Diff>>::Output>
    where
        Tr2: for<'a> TraceReader<Key<'a>=&'a K, Time=G::Timestamp>+Clone+'static,
        R: Multiply<Tr2::Diff>,
        <R as Multiply<Tr2::Diff>>::Output: Semigroup+'static,
        I: IntoIterator,
        I::Item: Data,
        L: FnMut(&K,&V,Tr2::Val<'_>)->I+'static,
        ;

    /// An unsafe variant of `join_core` where the `result` closure takes additional arguments for `time` and
    /// `diff` as input and returns an iterator over `(data, time, diff)` triplets. This allows for more
    /// flexibility, but is more error-prone.
    ///
    /// Each matching pair of records `(key, val1)` and `(key, val2)` are subjected to the `result` function,
    /// which produces something implementing `IntoIterator`, where the output collection will have an entry
    /// for every value returned by the iterator.
    ///
    /// This trait is implemented for arrangements (`Arranged<G, T>`) rather than collections. The `Join` trait
    /// contains the implementations for collections.
    ///
    /// # Examples
    ///
    /// ```
    /// use differential_dataflow::input::Input;
    /// use differential_dataflow::operators::arrange::ArrangeByKey;
    /// use differential_dataflow::operators::join::JoinCore;
    /// use differential_dataflow::trace::Trace;
    ///
    /// ::timely::example(|scope| {
    ///
    ///     let x = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(0u32, 1), (1, 3)]).1
    ///                  .arrange_by_key();
    ///     let y = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(0, 'a'), (1, 'b')]).1
    ///                  .arrange_by_key();
    ///
    ///     let z = scope.new_collection_from(vec![(1, 'a'), (3, 'b'), (3, 'b'), (3, 'b')]).1;
    ///
    ///     // Returned values have weight `a`
    ///     x.join_core_internal_unsafe(&y, |_key, &a, &b, &t, &r1, &r2| Some(((a, b), t.clone(), a)))
    ///      .assert_eq(&z);
    /// });
    /// ```
    fn join_core_internal_unsafe<Tr2,I,L,D,ROut> (&self, stream2: &Arranged<G,Tr2>, result: L) -> Collection<G,D,ROut>
    where
        Tr2: for<'a> TraceReader<Key<'a>=&'a K, Time=G::Timestamp>+Clone+'static,
        D: Data,
        ROut: Semigroup+'static,
        I: IntoIterator<Item=(D, G::Timestamp, ROut)>,
        L: for<'a> FnMut(&K,&V,Tr2::Val<'_>,&G::Timestamp,&R,&Tr2::Diff)->I+'static,
        ;
}


impl<G, K, V, R> JoinCore<G, K, V, R> for Collection<G, (K, V), R>
where
    G: Scope,
    K: ExchangeData+Hashable,
    V: ExchangeData,
    R: ExchangeData+Semigroup,
    G::Timestamp: Lattice+Ord,
{
    fn join_core<Tr2,I,L> (&self, stream2: &Arranged<G,Tr2>, result: L) -> Collection<G,I::Item,<R as Multiply<Tr2::Diff>>::Output>
    where
        Tr2: for<'a> TraceReader<Key<'a>=&'a K, Time=G::Timestamp>+Clone+'static,
        R: Multiply<Tr2::Diff>,
        <R as Multiply<Tr2::Diff>>::Output: Semigroup+'static,
        I: IntoIterator,
        I::Item: Data,
        L: FnMut(&K,&V,Tr2::Val<'_>)->I+'static,
    {
        self.arrange_by_key()
            .join_core(stream2, result)
    }

    fn join_core_internal_unsafe<Tr2,I,L,D,ROut> (&self, stream2: &Arranged<G,Tr2>, result: L) -> Collection<G,D,ROut>
    where
        Tr2: for<'a> TraceReader<Key<'a>=&'a K, Time=G::Timestamp>+Clone+'static,
        I: IntoIterator<Item=(D, G::Timestamp, ROut)>,
        L: FnMut(&K,&V,Tr2::Val<'_>,&G::Timestamp,&R,&Tr2::Diff)->I+'static,
        D: Data,
        ROut: Semigroup+'static,
    {
        self.arrange_by_key().join_core_internal_unsafe(stream2, result)
    }
}

/// The session passed to join closures.
pub type JoinSession<'a, T, CB, C> = Session<'a, T, EffortBuilder<CB>, Counter<T, C, Tee<T, C>>>;

/// A container builder that tracks the length of outputs to estimate the effort of join closures.
#[derive(Default, Debug)]
pub struct EffortBuilder<CB>(pub std::cell::Cell<usize>, pub CB);

impl<CB: ContainerBuilder> ContainerBuilder for EffortBuilder<CB> {
    type Container = CB::Container;

    #[inline]
    fn extract(&mut self) -> Option<&mut Self::Container> {
        let extracted = self.1.extract();
        self.0.replace(self.0.take() + extracted.as_ref().map_or(0, |e| e.len()));
        extracted
    }

    #[inline]
    fn finish(&mut self) -> Option<&mut Self::Container> {
        let finished = self.1.finish();
        self.0.replace(self.0.take() + finished.as_ref().map_or(0, |e| e.len()));
        finished
    }
}

impl<CB: PushInto<D>, D> PushInto<D> for EffortBuilder<CB> {
    #[inline]
    fn push_into(&mut self, item: D) {
        self.1.push_into(item);
    }
}

/// An equijoin of two traces, sharing a common key type.
///
/// This method exists to provide join functionality without opinions on the specific input types, keys and values,
/// that should be presented. The two traces here can have arbitrary key and value types, which can be unsized and
/// even potentially unrelated to the input collection data. Importantly, the key and value types could be generic
/// associated types (GATs) of the traces, and we would seemingly struggle to frame these types as trait arguments.
///
/// The implementation produces a caller-specified container. Implementations can use [`AsCollection`] to wrap the
/// output stream in a collection.
///
/// The "correctness" of this method depends heavily on the behavior of the supplied `result` function.
///
/// [`AsCollection`]: crate::collection::AsCollection
pub fn join_traces<G, T1, T2, L, CB>(arranged1: &Arranged<G,T1>, arranged2: &Arranged<G,T2>, mut result: L) -> StreamCore<G, CB::Container>
where
    G: Scope<Timestamp=T1::Time>,
    T1: TraceReader+Clone+'static,
    T2: for<'a> TraceReader<Key<'a>=T1::Key<'a>, Time=T1::Time>+Clone+'static,
    L: FnMut(T1::Key<'_>,T1::Val<'_>,T2::Val<'_>,&G::Timestamp,&T1::Diff,&T2::Diff,&mut JoinSession<T1::Time, CB, CB::Container>)+'static,
    CB: ContainerBuilder + 'static,
{
    // Rename traces for symmetry from here on out.
    let mut trace1 = arranged1.trace.clone();
    let mut trace2 = arranged2.trace.clone();

    arranged1.stream.binary_frontier(&arranged2.stream, Pipeline, Pipeline, "Join", move |capability, info| {

        // Acquire an activator to reschedule the operator when it has unfinished work.
        use timely::scheduling::Activator;
        let activations = arranged1.stream.scope().activations().clone();
        let activator = Activator::new(info.address, activations);

        // Our initial invariants are that for each trace, physical compaction is less or equal the trace's upper bound.
        // These invariants ensure that we can reference observed batch frontiers from `_start_upper` onward, as long as
        // we maintain our physical compaction capabilities appropriately. These assertions are tested as we load up the
        // initial work for the two traces, and before the operator is constructed.

        // Acknowledged frontier for each input.
        // These two are used exclusively to track batch boundaries on which we may want/need to call `cursor_through`.
        // They will drive our physical compaction of each trace, and we want to maintain at all times that each is beyond
        // the physical compaction frontier of their corresponding trace.
        // Should we ever *drop* a trace, these are 1. much harder to maintain correctly, but 2. no longer used.
        use timely::progress::frontier::Antichain;
        let mut acknowledged1 = Antichain::from_elem(<G::Timestamp>::minimum());
        let mut acknowledged2 = Antichain::from_elem(<G::Timestamp>::minimum());

        // deferred work of batches from each input.
        let mut todo1 = std::collections::VecDeque::new();
        let mut todo2 = std::collections::VecDeque::new();

        // We'll unload the initial batches here, to put ourselves in a less non-deterministic state to start.
        trace1.map_batches(|batch1| {
            acknowledged1.clone_from(batch1.upper());
            // No `todo1` work here, because we haven't accepted anything into `batches2` yet.
            // It is effectively "empty", because we choose to drain `trace1` before `trace2`.
            // Once we start streaming batches in, we will need to respond to new batches from
            // `input1` with logic that would have otherwise been here. Check out the next loop
            // for the structure.
        });
        // At this point, `ack1` should exactly equal `trace1.read_upper()`, as they are both determined by
        // iterating through batches and capturing the upper bound. This is a great moment to assert that
        // `trace1`'s physical compaction frontier is before the frontier of completed times in `trace1`.
        // TODO: in the case that this does not hold, instead "upgrade" the physical compaction frontier.
        assert!(PartialOrder::less_equal(&trace1.get_physical_compaction(), &acknowledged1.borrow()));

        // We capture batch2 cursors first and establish work second to avoid taking a `RefCell` lock
        // on both traces at the same time, as they could be the same trace and this would panic.
        let mut batch2_cursors = Vec::new();
        trace2.map_batches(|batch2| {
            acknowledged2.clone_from(batch2.upper());
            batch2_cursors.push((batch2.cursor(), batch2.clone()));
        });
        // At this point, `ack2` should exactly equal `trace2.read_upper()`, as they are both determined by
        // iterating through batches and capturing the upper bound. This is a great moment to assert that
        // `trace2`'s physical compaction frontier is before the frontier of completed times in `trace2`.
        // TODO: in the case that this does not hold, instead "upgrade" the physical compaction frontier.
        assert!(PartialOrder::less_equal(&trace2.get_physical_compaction(), &acknowledged2.borrow()));

        // Load up deferred work using trace2 cursors and batches captured just above.
        for (batch2_cursor, batch2) in batch2_cursors.into_iter() {
            // It is safe to ask for `ack1` because we have confirmed it to be in advance of `distinguish_since`.
            let (trace1_cursor, trace1_storage) = trace1.cursor_through(acknowledged1.borrow()).unwrap();
            // We could downgrade the capability here, but doing so is a bit complicated mathematically.
            // TODO: downgrade the capability by searching out the one time in `batch2.lower()` and not
            // in `batch2.upper()`. Only necessary for non-empty batches, as empty batches may not have
            // that property.
            todo2.push_back(Deferred::new(trace1_cursor, trace1_storage, batch2_cursor, batch2.clone(), capability.clone()));
        }

        // Droppable handles to shared trace data structures.
        let mut trace1_option = Some(trace1);
        let mut trace2_option = Some(trace2);

        // Swappable buffers for input extraction.
        let mut input1_buffer = Vec::new();
        let mut input2_buffer = Vec::new();

        move |input1, input2, output| {

            // 1. Consuming input.
            //
            // The join computation repeatedly accepts batches of updates from each of its inputs.
            //
            // For each accepted batch, it prepares a work-item to join the batch against previously "accepted"
            // updates from its other input. It is important to track which updates have been accepted, because
            // we use a shared trace and there may be updates present that are in advance of this accepted bound.
            //
            // Batches are accepted: 1. in bulk at start-up (above), 2. as we observe them in the input stream,
            // and 3. if the trace can confirm a region of empty space directly following our accepted bound.
            // This last case is a consequence of our inability to transmit empty batches, as they may be formed
            // in the absence of timely dataflow capabilities.

            // Drain input 1, prepare work.
            input1.for_each(|capability, data| {
                // This test *should* always pass, as we only drop a trace in response to the other input emptying.
                if let Some(ref mut trace2) = trace2_option {
                    let capability = capability.retain();
                    data.swap(&mut input1_buffer);
                    for batch1 in input1_buffer.drain(..) {
                        // Ignore any pre-loaded data.
                        if PartialOrder::less_equal(&acknowledged1, batch1.lower()) {
                            if !batch1.is_empty() {
                                // It is safe to ask for `ack2` as we validated that it was at least `get_physical_compaction()`
                                // at start-up, and have held back physical compaction ever since.
                                let (trace2_cursor, trace2_storage) = trace2.cursor_through(acknowledged2.borrow()).unwrap();
                                let batch1_cursor = batch1.cursor();
                                todo1.push_back(Deferred::new(trace2_cursor, trace2_storage, batch1_cursor, batch1.clone(), capability.clone()));
                            }

                            // To update `acknowledged1` we might presume that `batch1.lower` should equal it, but we
                            // may have skipped over empty batches. Still, the batches are in-order, and we should be
                            // able to just assume the most recent `batch1.upper`
                            debug_assert!(PartialOrder::less_equal(&acknowledged1, batch1.upper()));
                            acknowledged1.clone_from(batch1.upper());
                        }
                    }
                }
                else { panic!("`trace2_option` dropped before `input1` emptied!"); }
            });

            // Drain input 2, prepare work.
            input2.for_each(|capability, data| {
                // This test *should* always pass, as we only drop a trace in response to the other input emptying.
                if let Some(ref mut trace1) = trace1_option {
                    let capability = capability.retain();
                    data.swap(&mut input2_buffer);
                    for batch2 in input2_buffer.drain(..) {
                        // Ignore any pre-loaded data.
                        if PartialOrder::less_equal(&acknowledged2, batch2.lower()) {
                            if !batch2.is_empty() {
                                // It is safe to ask for `ack1` as we validated that it was at least `get_physical_compaction()`
                                // at start-up, and have held back physical compaction ever since.
                                let (trace1_cursor, trace1_storage) = trace1.cursor_through(acknowledged1.borrow()).unwrap();
                                let batch2_cursor = batch2.cursor();
                                todo2.push_back(Deferred::new(trace1_cursor, trace1_storage, batch2_cursor, batch2.clone(), capability.clone()));
                            }

                            // To update `acknowledged2` we might presume that `batch2.lower` should equal it, but we
                            // may have skipped over empty batches. Still, the batches are in-order, and we should be
                            // able to just assume the most recent `batch2.upper`
                            debug_assert!(PartialOrder::less_equal(&acknowledged2, batch2.upper()));
                            acknowledged2.clone_from(batch2.upper());
                        }
                    }
                }
                else { panic!("`trace1_option` dropped before `input2` emptied!"); }
            });

            // Advance acknowledged frontiers through any empty regions that we may not receive as batches.
            if let Some(trace1) = trace1_option.as_mut() {
                trace1.advance_upper(&mut acknowledged1);
            }
            if let Some(trace2) = trace2_option.as_mut() {
                trace2.advance_upper(&mut acknowledged2);
            }

            // 2. Join computation.
            //
            // For each of the inputs, we do some amount of work (measured in terms of number
            // of output records produced). This is meant to yield control to allow downstream
            // operators to consume and reduce the output, but it it also means to provide some
            // degree of responsiveness. There is a potential risk here that if we fall behind
            // then the increasing queues hold back physical compaction of the underlying traces
            // which results in unintentionally quadratic processing time (each batch of either
            // input must scan all batches from the other input).

            // Perform some amount of outstanding work.
            let mut fuel = 1_000_000;
            while !todo1.is_empty() && fuel > 0 {
                todo1.front_mut().unwrap().work(
                    output,
                    |k,v2,v1,t,r2,r1,c| result(k,v1,v2,t,r1,r2,c),
                    &mut fuel
                );
                if !todo1.front().unwrap().work_remains() { todo1.pop_front(); }
            }

            // Perform some amount of outstanding work.
            let mut fuel = 1_000_000;
            while !todo2.is_empty() && fuel > 0 {
                todo2.front_mut().unwrap().work(
                    output,
                    |k,v1,v2,t,r1,r2,c| result(k,v1,v2,t,r1,r2,c),
                    &mut fuel
                );
                if !todo2.front().unwrap().work_remains() { todo2.pop_front(); }
            }

            // Re-activate operator if work remains.
            if !todo1.is_empty() || !todo2.is_empty() {
                activator.activate();
            }

            // 3. Trace maintenance.
            //
            // Importantly, we use `input.frontier()` here rather than `acknowledged` to track
            // the progress of an input, because should we ever drop one of the traces we will
            // lose the ability to extract information from anything other than the input.
            // For example, if we dropped `trace2` we would not be able to use `advance_upper`
            // to keep `acknowledged2` up to date wrt empty batches, and would hold back logical
            // compaction of `trace1`.

            // Maintain `trace1`. Drop if `input2` is empty, or advance based on future needs.
            if let Some(trace1) = trace1_option.as_mut() {
                if input2.frontier().is_empty() { trace1_option = None; }
                else {
                    // Allow `trace1` to compact logically up to the frontier we may yet receive,
                    // in the opposing input (`input2`). All `input2` times will be beyond this
                    // frontier, and joined times only need to be accurate when advanced to it.
                    trace1.set_logical_compaction(input2.frontier().frontier());
                    // Allow `trace1` to compact physically up to the upper bound of batches we
                    // have received in its input (`input1`). We will not require a cursor that
                    // is not beyond this bound.
                    trace1.set_physical_compaction(acknowledged1.borrow());
                }
            }

            // Maintain `trace2`. Drop if `input1` is empty, or advance based on future needs.
            if let Some(trace2) = trace2_option.as_mut() {
                if input1.frontier().is_empty() { trace2_option = None;}
                else {
                    // Allow `trace2` to compact logically up to the frontier we may yet receive,
                    // in the opposing input (`input1`). All `input1` times will be beyond this
                    // frontier, and joined times only need to be accurate when advanced to it.
                    trace2.set_logical_compaction(input1.frontier().frontier());
                    // Allow `trace2` to compact physically up to the upper bound of batches we
                    // have received in its input (`input2`). We will not require a cursor that
                    // is not beyond this bound.
                    trace2.set_physical_compaction(acknowledged2.borrow());
                }
            }
        }
    })
}


/// Deferred join computation.
///
/// The structure wraps cursors which allow us to play out join computation at whatever rate we like.
/// This allows us to avoid producing and buffering massive amounts of data, without giving the timely
/// dataflow system a chance to run operators that can consume and aggregate the data.
struct Deferred<T, C1, C2>
where
    T: Timestamp+Lattice+Ord,
    C1: Cursor<Time=T>,
    C2: for<'a> Cursor<Key<'a>=C1::Key<'a>, Time=T>,
{
    trace: C1,
    trace_storage: C1::Storage,
    batch: C2,
    batch_storage: C2::Storage,
    capability: Capability<T>,
    done: bool,
}

impl<T, C1, C2> Deferred<T, C1, C2>
where
    C1: Cursor<Time=T>,
    C2: for<'a> Cursor<Key<'a>=C1::Key<'a>, Time=T>,
    T: Timestamp+Lattice+Ord,
{
    fn new(trace: C1, trace_storage: C1::Storage, batch: C2, batch_storage: C2::Storage, capability: Capability<T>) -> Self {
        Deferred {
            trace,
            trace_storage,
            batch,
            batch_storage,
            capability,
            done: false,
        }
    }

    fn work_remains(&self) -> bool {
        !self.done
    }

    /// Process keys until at least `fuel` output tuples produced, or the work is exhausted.
    #[inline(never)]
    fn work<L, CB: ContainerBuilder>(&mut self, output: &mut OutputHandleCore<T, EffortBuilder<CB>, Tee<T, CB::Container>>, mut logic: L, fuel: &mut usize)
    where
        L: for<'a> FnMut(C1::Key<'a>, C1::Val<'a>, C2::Val<'a>, &T, &C1::Diff, &C2::Diff, &mut JoinSession<T, CB, CB::Container>),
    {

        let meet = self.capability.time();

        let mut effort = 0;
        let mut session = output.session_with_builder(&self.capability);

        let trace_storage = &self.trace_storage;
        let batch_storage = &self.batch_storage;

        let trace = &mut self.trace;
        let batch = &mut self.batch;

        let mut thinker = JoinThinker::new();

        while batch.key_valid(batch_storage) && trace.key_valid(trace_storage) && effort < *fuel {

            match trace.key(trace_storage).cmp(&batch.key(batch_storage)) {
                Ordering::Less => trace.seek_key(trace_storage, batch.key(batch_storage)),
                Ordering::Greater => batch.seek_key(batch_storage, trace.key(trace_storage)),
                Ordering::Equal => {

                    use crate::trace::cursor::IntoOwned;
                    
                    thinker.history1.edits.load(trace, trace_storage, |time| {
                        let mut time = time.into_owned();
                        time.join_assign(meet);
                        time
                    });
                    thinker.history2.edits.load(batch, batch_storage, |time| time.into_owned());

                    // populate `temp` with the results in the best way we know how.
                    thinker.think(|v1,v2,t,r1,r2| {
                        let key = batch.key(batch_storage);
                        logic(key, v1, v2, &t, r1, r2, &mut session);
                    });

                    // TODO: Effort isn't perfectly tracked as we might still have some data in the
                    // session at the moment it's dropped.
                    effort += session.builder().0.take();
                    batch.step_key(batch_storage);
                    trace.step_key(trace_storage);

                    thinker.history1.clear();
                    thinker.history2.clear();
                }
            }
        }
        self.done = !batch.key_valid(batch_storage) || !trace.key_valid(trace_storage);

        if effort > *fuel { *fuel = 0; }
        else              { *fuel -= effort; }
    }
}

struct JoinThinker<'a, C1, C2>
where
    C1: Cursor,
    C2: Cursor<Time = C1::Time>,
{
    pub history1: ValueHistory<'a, C1>,
    pub history2: ValueHistory<'a, C2>,
}

impl<'a, C1, C2> JoinThinker<'a, C1, C2>
where
    C1: Cursor,
    C2: Cursor<Time = C1::Time>,
{
    fn new() -> Self {
        JoinThinker {
            history1: ValueHistory::new(),
            history2: ValueHistory::new(),
        }
    }

    fn think<F: FnMut(C1::Val<'a>,C2::Val<'a>,C1::Time,&C1::Diff,&C2::Diff)>(&mut self, mut results: F) {

        // for reasonably sized edits, do the dead-simple thing.
        if self.history1.edits.len() < 10 || self.history2.edits.len() < 10 {
            self.history1.edits.map(|v1, t1, d1| {
                self.history2.edits.map(|v2, t2, d2| {
                    results(v1, v2, t1.join(t2), d1, d2);
                })
            })
        }
        else {

            let mut replay1 = self.history1.replay();
            let mut replay2 = self.history2.replay();

            // TODO: It seems like there is probably a good deal of redundant `advance_buffer_by`
            //       in here. If a time is ever repeated, for example, the call will be identical
            //       and accomplish nothing. If only a single record has been added, it may not
            //       be worth the time to collapse (advance, re-sort) the data when a linear scan
            //       is sufficient.

            while !replay1.is_done() && !replay2.is_done() {

                if replay1.time().unwrap().cmp(replay2.time().unwrap()) == ::std::cmp::Ordering::Less {
                    replay2.advance_buffer_by(replay1.meet().unwrap());
                    for &((val2, ref time2), ref diff2) in replay2.buffer().iter() {
                        let (val1, time1, diff1) = replay1.edit().unwrap();
                        results(val1, val2, time1.join(time2), diff1, diff2);
                    }
                    replay1.step();
                }
                else {
                    replay1.advance_buffer_by(replay2.meet().unwrap());
                    for &((val1, ref time1), ref diff1) in replay1.buffer().iter() {
                        let (val2, time2, diff2) = replay2.edit().unwrap();
                        results(val1, val2, time1.join(time2), diff1, diff2);
                    }
                    replay2.step();
                }
            }

            while !replay1.is_done() {
                replay2.advance_buffer_by(replay1.meet().unwrap());
                for &((val2, ref time2), ref diff2) in replay2.buffer().iter() {
                    let (val1, time1, diff1) = replay1.edit().unwrap();
                    results(val1, val2, time1.join(time2), diff1, diff2);
                }
                replay1.step();
            }
            while !replay2.is_done() {
                replay1.advance_buffer_by(replay2.meet().unwrap());
                for &((val1, ref time1), ref diff1) in replay1.buffer().iter() {
                    let (val2, time2, diff2) = replay2.edit().unwrap();
                    results(val1, val2, time1.join(time2), diff1, diff2);
                }
                replay2.step();
            }
        }
    }
}